The unveiling of India's squad for the Asia Cup 2023 has sparked a fiery debate within the cricketing community. As fans and experts weigh in on the team's composition, diverse opinions have emerged, highlighting perceived 'flaws' in the lineup. One prominent concern is the need for a solid backup option for Hardik Pandya, a sentiment voiced by former India cricketer Gautam Gambhir.

Gautam Gambhir has expressed his view on the necessity of having a proper substitute for the versatile Hardik Pandya. While acknowledging Shardul Thakur's potential as a productive batsman, Gambhir does not consider him an ideal backup for Hardik. Instead, he asserts that Shivam Dube's recent form warrants serious consideration. Gambhir believes that Dube's all-around capabilities make him a suitable candidate to step in for Hardik.

"One name they (the select should have considered is Shivam Dube because of the kind of form he is in. You need a backup for Hardik Pandya. Shardul Thakur can't be that. Shardul Thakur cannot be Hardik's backup," he said in a chat on Star Sports.

However, former India cricketer Sunil Joshi offers a contrasting perspective, urging caution against mixing One Day Internationals (ODIs) and Twenty20 Internationals (T20Is). Joshi contends that while Dube might excel in T20s, the dynamic of a different format and tournament could pose challenges. He emphasizes Dube's struggles in bowling and fielding aspects, asserting that these factors must also be considered.

Joshi said, "No, I don't think so. We have seen Shivam Dube. He would've been scoring in T20s, but this is entirely format and a different tournament. With due respect to Gautam, this is my view. Shivam Dube has struggled with the ball and also in the field."

Shifting the focus to India's ODI squad for the Asia Cup, Gautam Gambhir acknowledges its overall strength but presents his take on potential improvements. He suggests an additional wrist spinner could enhance the squad's balance, proposing Yuzvendra Chahal or Ravi Bishnoi as worthy options. In Gambhir's assessment, India's playing conditions necessitate the inclusion of two wrist spinners, especially when competing on home soil.

"It's a decent squad; according to me,, a nice squad is picked, but ,a wrist spinner is needed somewhere. It's a seam-heavy squad, and I believe either Ravi Bishnoi or Yuzvendra Chahal should have been picked because of conditions; when you are playing in India, it's important to keep two wrist spinners in the squad," he opined.

Gambhir underscores the importance of variety in the bowling attack, specifically highlighting the need for wrist spinners. He observes that the current squad leans heavily towards seam bowling, with only one wrist spinner and two left-arm spinners. Gambhir advocates adding a wrist spinner to address this perceived imbalance, suggesting that this adjustment would lend more depth and dimension to India's bowling options.

[“One minor injury, you will play IPL but not for India”: Kapil Dev’s Scathing Attack At Indian Star Player](Read also"One minor injury, you will play IPL but not for India": Kapil Dev's Scathing Attack At Indian Star PlayerKapil Dev, the legendary cricketer and captain of the 1983 World Cup-winning Indian team, is known for speaking his mind. In a recent interview with The Week, he…)

Gambhir further delves into the nuances of squad selection by suggesting a rotation strategy. He contends that Mohammad Shami could be given a break, leveraging the exceptional form of Prasidh Krishna. By making this tactical adjustment, Gambhir believes India could accommodate a wrist spinner without compromising the overall potency of the pace attack.

"Somewhere, it's a one-dimensional attack, two left-arm spinners, one wrist spinner, and other pacers, and it's a seam-heavy attack (four-seamers). I think it's a place where they could do better if they have selected one out of either leg-spinner. I believe you could give a break to Mohammad Shami and the form in which Prasidh Krishna is; you could pick a wrist spinner," Gambhir explained.

View this youtube post ↗